In this case, the victor is me, and the spoils are a blue ribbon and bragging rights. Clubby and I both brewed Saisons to enter into the High Plains Drafters Eight Seconds of Froth competition. We didn’t expect to win. What we really wanted was feedback and constructive criticism of our beers. Anytime you have BJCP judges judging your beer, you will get great feedback and constructive criticism. They are not out to make you feel like crap, but actually help you identify problems and hopefully make better beer. Anyways, that’s what we wanted. That, and to have a little competition between ourselves. Neither of us have brewed a Saison, so it was mostly just guess work formulating a recipe. Who would be the better brewmaster? Greg or Clubby? I figured we would place last and second last, not sure who would be the best worst brewer. We brewed both, shipped both off, and waited.
So I was lounging one night, and Clubby texts me. This is our conversation:
Clubby: Any news on the homebrew contest?
Greg: Not yet, I think it took a few weeks to hear from the last one
Clubby: I gotcha. I’m curious to see what one did better. Not for competition sake. Just to see what one was more of a classic Saison.
Greg: I hope I kicked your BLEEPING (censored for the kiddies) ASS (not a bad word)! I really want to make these again, using their suggestions
Clubby:Yea, we definitely have to. And you aren’t going to beat me!
Fast forward approximately 10 hours later, I checked the website to see, and sure enough the winners were posted. “OK, let me see who beat us in the Belgian and French Ale category.” HOLY CRAP!!! My name is in the first place spot! No Clubby in the 2 hole, 3 hole, and oddly placed 3.5 hole. I won! I beat that loser into the ground! I am the best homebrewer between the 2 of us! Wait until I rub this in his big, smooth face! So after all that exclaiming, I texted him the great news. I was actually in disbelief. How could I place 1st? Needless to say, Clubby acted professionally and congratulated me. I am happy that I won. So was he. So was everybody that I told. We always knew that we brew good beer, but to have people who don’t know you drink your beer, and give you positive feedback, it feels really good. Clubby still hasn’t received his scorcard yet, I am sure it’s on it’s way, but we’ll see how well he did. I think his was really good too, the only negative that I can really think of is lack of carbonation. We’ll just have to wait and see what the judges had to say.
For my scorecards, here’s what the judges had to say.
Final Assigned Score: 32/50
Judge 1 Experienced Non BJCP
Aroma 7/12: Moderate hop aroma, not a ton of fruit in aroma
Appearance 2/3: Hazy golden in color. Decent head retention
Flavor 10/20: Spicy, low malt character
Mouthfeel 4/5: light body, medium low alcohol, good high carbonation
Overall Impression 7/10: Overall pretty good, light spicy/earthy
Total 30/50
Judge 2 National BJCP
Aroma 7/12: Moderate fruitiness, very faint hops, (can’t decipher word)-good, slight mustiness
Appearance 2/3: milky pale orange, nice tight head
Flavor 14/20: nice spice & pepper, some coriander notes, missing the distinctive fruitiness. medium hop bitterness and restrained flavor. very low malt profile, slight solvent in (can’t decipher word)
Mouthfeel 4/5: nice jumpy CO2. medium body lightened up by CO2
Overall Impression 6/10: complex beer that can use some more fruitiness. Well made beer, no significant faults. a little tweaking will go a long way.
Total 33/50
So there you have it. My award winning beer. Feel free to congratulate me excessively and throw money at me to show your love and affection. When Clubby receives his results I’ll post them too, for all we know, he could have scored 2 points below me.